Carpet cleaning isn’t just about keeping your floors looking great; it’s essential for maintaining a clean, healthy workspace.

Let's explore the three main carpet cleaning methods to determine which one reigns supreme.

Hot water extraction

The hot water extraction (HWE) method, also known as steam cleaning, is one of the most traditional and widely used techniques.

How it works:

1. Pre-vacuum carpet with a power head brush action HEPA vacuum.
2. Apply carpet cleaning solution to high-traffic areas.
3. Rinse and extract with hot water using an HWE unit and wand.
4. Allow carpets to dry, which takes between 2 to 6 hours depending on the building environment.

This method requires intensive training and well-maintained equipment to be successful. However, in my experience, it is often implemented by untrained staff with poorly serviced equipment, leading to failures in the commercial carpet cleaning industry.

For the Hot Water Extraction method to work effectively, several components need to be controlled: pre-spray, water temperature, water pressure, and the wand for extraction. Additionally, machine maintenance is essential, including water pressure valves, filters, hoses, wand and wand jets, wastewater tanks, inlets, and outlets. With so many variables at play, experience is crucial to ensure all components are working optimally.

The HWE method has the highest power consumption, the highest water usage, and generates the most wastewater of the three methods. It's the noisiest, takes the longest time to dry, and is the most disruptive to the office working environment.

Despite these challenges, when implemented correctly with trained staff and well-serviced equipment, it is extremely successful. It's excellent for restoring heavily soiled carpets and pairs well with the Low Moisture method for certain carpet restoration projects. It's ideal for annual carpet cleans, one-off projects, extracting spills, and removing difficult builders’ spills, debris, and marks. However, it is not as environmentally friendly as the other methods.

Dry compound cleaning

The dry compound method represents the opposite end of the spectrum from HWE. It’s a technique that relies on minimal water usage, making it ideal for specific carpet types and environments.

How it works:

1. Pre-vacuum the carpet.
2. Apply the dry compound to the carpet.
3. Agitate with a counter-rotating brush machine.
4. Allow the compound to dry.
5. Vacuum the dry compound from the carpet.

This procedure utilises a dry compound powder, containing detergents and solvents, that is distributed over the carpet. The powder is agitated into the fibres using a counter-rotating brush machine. As it absorbs soil, the compound changes appearance and colour, signalling that it's actively cleaning. Once dry, the compound is vacuumed away.

While this method has proven effective, it is notably the most expensive in terms of both labour and consumables. The increased labor costs stem from the application, agitation, and subsequent removal of the compound. Meanwhile, the cost of the compound itself tends to be higher than that of cleaning solutions used in alternative methods.

Despite its cost, the dry compound method offers unique benefits, particularly for carpets that are water-sensitive, dyed with water-soluble colours, or at risk of shrinkage, such as sisal or seagrass. It also works well in regular carpet maintenance programs, where only light cleaning is needed. However, it may not be as economical for heavily soiled carpets. On the bright side, it's environmentally friendly and operates with low noise levels.

Low moisture encapsulation cleaning

The Low Moisture Encapsulation method is the newest addition to the carpet cleaning arsenal and offers a balance of effectiveness and efficiency. It’s particularly suited for modern commercial environments.

How it works:

1. Pre-vacuuming: Start with an upright brush action vacuum cleaner.
2. Pre-spray: Apply an encapsulation/crystallisation solution to the carpets.
3. Agitation: Use a counter-rotating brush machine.
4. Post-cleaning maintenance: Regular vacuuming over time removes the encapsulated/crystallised soils.

The Low Moisture Method is also recognised under several other names, such as encapsulation cleaning and crystallisation cleaning. These names aptly describe the process: the solution surrounds the dirt in a tiny crystal, and then these crystals are removed through dry vacuuming. The encapsulation method uses chemistry specifically designed for this purpose, formulated to break down various soils with special polymers. These polymers surround and bind to soil particles, leaving no residue on the carpet fibres. When used correctly, this method leaves carpets clean, refreshed, and less prone to rapid soiling.

Why choose the low moisture method?

To me, this system is the all-around nice guy. It's economical, produces low noise, and causes no disruption to the working environment. It cleans effectively, dries quickly, and is the most environmentally friendly of all three methods we've discussed. With low power consumption, minimal water use, and reduced waste disposal, it’s an excellent choice for carpet maintenance programs.

A note on carpet longevity

A common misconception is that frequent cleaning shortens carpet lifespan. In reality, grit and soil are the true culprits in reducing carpet life, as they grind against the pile when walked on.

Therefore, the more often you clean your carpet and remove these elements, the longer it will last.

‍